14 Things You Should Never Buy at Sam’s Club (2024)

Shopping at Sam's Club can be a fantastic way to save money on everyday purchases. Although the per unit savings can be quite attractive, buying certain goods there is not so cost-effective.

Some things at Sam's Club are just a waste of money. When planning your next Sam's Club run, strike these 14 items off your shopping list.

Editor's note: Prices are subject to change and may vary by location.

Sam’s Club specializes in bulk savings, but fresh fruit and vegetables have short shelf lives. When bought in bulk, they often spoil before you can eat them.

Save your veggie purchases at Sam’s when you need 20 pounds of carrot sticks and red peppers for a party tray.

It turns out lotion isn’t shelf-stable, or at least not as shelf-stable as one would like. Once you unseal a bottle, it’s generally good for 12 to 24 months — although you should still adhere to any expiration dates stamped on the bottle.

Old lotion won’t harm you, but it won’t be as effective. If not stored properly, harmful bacteria can build up.

If you’re not a heavy dairy drinker, hold off on purchasing it at Sam’s Club. It only sells milk by the gallon, while other grocery stores sell it by quart or half-gallon. This gives you time to consume the milk before it goes bad.

As a mom who has used Maker’s Mark diapers before, I can tell you I am not a fan. Compared to Pampers or Huggies, they leak more often. Plus, they’re not even the cheapest.

Per unit, Maker’s Mark diapers start at $0.15 each, matching Target’s pricing for Up & Up.Target, however, has regular diaper promotions that make their diapers much cheaper, like spending $50 to $100 on diaper goods to get a gift card of $10 to $30.

As with body lotion, shampoo and conditioner can lose effectiveness with age. Don't buy that jumbo three-pack unless you and your whole household use the same hair products.

Beyond wasting your money, you could be hurting your hair. Over time, ingredients separate and become unstable, leading to bacterial contamination that causes irritation, dryness, follicle damage — and even hair loss.

Sam’s is known for selling cooking oil by the gallon, But you should skip it unless you have an army-sized family. Cooking and olive oils are good for up to four months.

Expired cooking oils can cause healthy fats to break down and harmful free radicals to start forming — not to mention the rancid taste that comes with it.

While spices typically can’t go bad (unless they get contaminated with other food products), they can go stale and bland over time.

Unopened, ground spices lose their potency quickly and typically don’t last beyond six months.

Buying gift wraps — especially in holiday-themed prints — can be a ginormous waste when purchased in packs of four or more. You’ll likely tire of the paper before you go through the entire roll, and dollar stores offer a cheaper way to get new-season variety every year.

Sam’s Club sells fresh salmon at the bargain price of $10.98 per pound. However, the farm-raised salmon you’ll find at the discount retailer has numerous health concerns.

Farm-raised salmon contain persistent organic pollutants (POPs) linked to type-2 diabetes, obesity, and increased risk of stroke. Red dye is added to color their gray-tinge flesh pink, and they also contain higher levels of saturated fat.

Although Sam’s Club and Walmart are the same company (both part of Walmart, Inc.), the prices aren’t always identical. Chobani Greek yogurt is just one example.

You can find variety packs at Sam’s Club with a per-ounce price of $0.21, while Walmart stores have similar packs starting at $0.17 per ounce.

If the cheapest price per unit is your top concern, make sure to compare prices closely in the weekly store ads.

Along with Greek yogurt, fresh chicken is another popular grocery item that can be cheaper at Walmart.

Currently, prices are nearly identical, with chicken running $2.67 per pound at Walmart versus $2.68 per pound at Sam’s Club, but at times, Walmart’s savings can be even greater.

And even if Sam’s were a couple of cents cheaper per pound, given the club fee of $50 per year, the savings in poultry may not be enough to justify your membership.

Some shoppers swear you should always buy gift cards at Sam's Club, but I would advise against it. On more than one occasion, I've been gifted a gift card (properly rung up) from Sam's Club that didn't work when I tried to redeem it.

Additionally, for true deal seekers, many gift card portals offer a much wider selection of gift cards and far deeper discounts.

Sam’s Club can be a fantastic store to save money, but not every item is a deal. Beyond the pitfalls of buying in bulk, review prices carefully. Amazon, Target, Costco, or even Walmart often have better “deals” than the popular warehouse giant.

Regardless of where you shop, consider paying with one of the best cash back credit cards to help you save more on your next shop.

Subscribe Today

Want extra-cash moves to come right to you?

Stop browsing endlessly. Get proven ways to earn pocket money, help cover rent, and crush your debt — sent to your inbox daily.